Friday, April 16, 2010

solitary confinement

Many people today contest the use of solitary confinement in the US as it is currently being practiced. i agree with the way that it is practiced today because i believe those who are closest to the situation, the prison officials, are most knowledgeable on the individuals in prison and because of this, they should be in complete control of the solitary confinement system. We should not put laws in place because we do not know all the details of the situation like those close to the prison do.
If i had to put a max amount of time that the prisoners could spend on solitary confinement however i would say about 5 years because that seems like a sufficient amount of time for any individual to be protected from others or to protect others from him. Building on this, i would also recommend that there be no cap on how many times that a prisoner could be put in solitary because many prisoners, i would imagine, go right back to the ways they did thing outside of solitary when they get out of it.
As of now, prisoners are not able to appeal the decisions of these prison officials and i would not give prisoners the ability to challenge or appeal their solitary confinement because for one, the prison officials would have to have proof for all of these cases and in many cases that would be extremely difficult to obtain and would lead to many dangerous prisoners out and about in the prison circulation.

1 comment:

  1. i agree with what you said about the people who are most knowlegdeable are the prison officials... i believe that is a true statment.

    ReplyDelete